Iraq Nightmare
2014-06-18 0:00

By Kevin MacDonald | Occidental Observer

Given the situation of sectarian/ethnic warfare in Iraq, I am posting an article that originally appeared in 2011. It’s amazing that academics like me are routinely pilloried as doing shoddy research and skewing everything they write about for political/ethnic reasons. But that does not apply at all to academic activists like Bernard Lewis, the much praised Princeton University professor who promised George W. Bush that all that was needed for a flourishing of Iraqi democracy of multiculturalism and human rights was a little military nudge. Iraq will never be like the West.

This logic continues with Tony Blair who absolves himself of any blame because “the sectarianism of the Maliki Government snuffed out what was a genuine opportunity to build a cohesive Iraq.”Blair writes as if to say, “if only they had a better leader, all would be well.”

Who could have possibly known that Maliki would simply reverse the Saddam’s modus vivendi and start oppressing the Sunnis? Bernard Lewis, for one. But Lewis was far more intent on carrying out Israel’s foreign policy interests than telling Bush the truth. A fragmented Iraq or an Iraq torn by war were equally attractive possibilities. Win-win.




Of all the lies that the neocons came up with to get the U.S. to invade Iraq, the one that most angers me was Bernard Lewis’s lie that Iraq just needed a little nudge in order to unleash the popular surge for democracy and republican government.

Lewis … argues that Arabs have a long history of consensus government, if not democracy, and that a modicum of outside force should be sufficient to democratize the area—a view that runs counter to the huge cultural differences between the Middle East and the West that stem ultimately from very different evolutionary pressures. (see here, p. 50)

I agree that the WMD lie created and promoted mainly by Paul Wolfowitz, Douglas Feith and Abraham Shulsky was critical. But Bernard Lewis deserves a special place in academic hell because he used his position as an elite academic to influence policy on behalf of his ethnic brethren in Israel and his close friends in the Likud government.

I assumed that Iraq would implode quite quickly after the U.S. left, but the pace is breathtaking. The LATimes report (“Iraq bombings kill 60, revive old fears“) shows that nothing has changed after 8-1/2 years of occupation, over 4400 U.S. armed forces dead and almost 32000 wounded, and over 100,000 Iraqis dead (see here). The Times article shows that the fundamental social structure hasn’t changed. The country remains divided along ethnic and religious lines.

The scenes of devastation were all too familiar after more than a dozen explosions ripped through the Iraqi capital Thursday, killing at least 60 people and injuring nearly 200, just days after the last U.S. troops left the country.

The attacks, some of the worst in Iraq this year, came in the midst of a political standoff between the country’s main Shiite Muslim and Sunni Arab factions. The dispute threatens to unravel a U.S.-backed power-sharing government, and is spreading anxiety over the prospect of a return to the sectarian bloodletting that devastated the country in recent years.

All the violence has not changed the basic fact that Iraq, like every other Arab culture, is a low-trust society:

“This crisis really is caused because there is pervasive distrust and an absence of institutions that can carry this kind of transition,” said Joost Hiltermann, an Iraq expert at the International Crisis Group. Prime Minister Nouri Maliki, a Shiite, has never trusted the Sunni politicians with whom he has been forced to share power, Hiltermann said.

Western societies have uniquely been high-trust societies, a point made, e.g., by Francis Fukuyama and a basic corollary of the psychology of Western individualism (see here, p. 27ff). The problem is that we think that everyone is “just like us”—willing and able to set up individualist societies with democratic and republican institutions. As Ian Morris writes in his Why the West Rules—For Now, people are pretty much the same the world over (see Brenton Sanderson’s review).We want to believe this so badly that it was easy to pull off the big lie. It’s the foundational lie of multi-culturalism.

[...]

Read the full article at: theoccidentalobserver.net



Tune into Red Ice Radio:

Frank Salter - War on Human Nature, Replacement Level Migration in the West & Crime of Diversity

Tom Sunic - Metapolitics, Paganism & European Identity

Vahan Setyan - Hour 1 - Armenian Roots of Civilization & The Armenian Genocide

Darrell Hamamoto - Hour 1 - The Dark Side of Asian America & Weaponized Political Correctness

Kevin MacDonald - The Dispossession of Europeans & Pathological Altruism

Patrick Henningsen - Hour 1 - The Politically Correct Matrix

Ramzpaul - Hour 1 - Multicultural Chaos, Peaceful Nationalism & White Guilt

Ricardo Duchesne - Hour 1 - The Uniqueness of Western Civilization & Multicultural Madness





Related Articles
Minority Rule: The Rise of Political Correctness (Documentary)
"New" Iraq a Nightmare for Women, Minority Groups
EU Multiculturalism is White Genocide - Graphic From David Dees
Multiculturalism: America’s most peaceful and least peaceful states
Mark Steyn’s Brilliant (and Funny) Critique of Multiculturalism
"Policy of multiculturalism in Europe has failed"
Psychopaths and The Multicultural Myth
Pentagon Spokesman Downplays Deteriorating Iraq Situation
Continued Carnage: Iraq disintegrating as insurgents advance; Kurds seize Kirkuk
What?! Obama claims ’Iraq invasion not as bad as Crimea’
Meanwhile In Iraq - Clashes, Bombings, Shootings Leave 96 Dead, 95 Wounded
Pat Tillman 2.0: Tale of Sgt. Peralta’s ‘Iraq War Heroism’ in Fallujah Was Total Fiction


Latest News from our Front Page

Pedophiles Now Demanding Equality - Wanting Their Equal Rights to Marriage
2015-06-30 2:06
Using the same tactics used by “gay” rights activists, pedophiles have begun to seek similar status arguing their desire for children is a sexual orientation no different than heterosexual or homosexuals. Critics of the homosexual lifestyle have long claimed that once it became acceptable to identify homosexuality as simply an “alternative lifestyle” or sexual orientation, logically nothing would be off limits ...
Time: Orthodox Christians Must Now Learn To Live as Exiles in Our Own Country
2015-06-30 2:21
Rod Dreher is a senior editor and blogger at The American Conservative. Voting Republican and other failed culture war strategies are not going to save us now. No, the sky is not falling — not yet, anyway — but with the Supreme Court ruling constitutionalizing same-sex marriage, the ground under our feet has shifted tectonically. It is hard to overstate the significance of ...
Obama: Americans need to shift religious views
2015-06-30 1:46
From RamZPaul: Friday, President Obama gave a speech in which he said Americans need to change their religious views to be accepting of gay marriage. http://www.examiner.com/article/obama... Source: ramzpaul
11 Fake European Towns and Landmarks Made in China
2015-06-30 1:09
We’ve known the Chinese to imitate almost everything. From luxury bags to whatever the fad is, they have it already freshly made. We’ve also known that Chinese tourists traveling around the world continue to increase due to rising incomes and less restrictive passport regime. Europe is one of the mostly visited continents and more campaigns have been launched in some ...
Russia calls for an investigation into the Moon landing
2015-06-29 21:06
A Russian official has has cast doubt on the first moon landings and demanded an investigation into what really happened after original Nasa footage of the event disappeared. Vladimir Markin, a spokesman for the Russian government's Investigative Committee, says he wants an inquiry after the video from 1969 and a piece of lunar rock, which was brought back to earth, went ...
More News »