New tool peeks into brain to measure consciousness
2013-08-15 0:00

From: Daily Republic

When people have a brain injury so severe that they canít squeeze a loved oneís hand or otherwise respond, there are few good ways to tell if they have any lingering awareness or are in a vegetative state. Now researchers have created a tool to peek inside the brain and measure varying levels of consciousness.

The work reported Wednesday is highly experimental, not ready for bedside use yet ó and if it pans out, a big question is how to use it without raising false hope. No one knows what level of consciousness at a certain point after injury really predicts recovery.

But it offers the hope that one day doctors might track consciousness nearly as easily as they check blood pressure.

ďConsciousness can grow and shrink,Ē said Dr. Marcello Massimini, a neurophysiologist at Italyís University of Milan who led the research to quantify just how much that is happening under different circumstances.

It seems obvious ó consciousness fades during deep sleep, and doctors can slip us under with anesthesia. Yet scientists donít have a good way to measure consciousness, especially when the very ill appear to be unconscious. Itís important to try to distinguish if patients are at least minimally conscious, and not in a vegetative state, because the sooner thereís some sign of awareness, the better the chance of recovery.

Today, doctors check if those patients can do things like blink or move a limb on command, or react to touch or pain. If not, scans of the brainís electrical activity may offer clues. Scientists even have put seemingly unconscious patients inside MRI scanners and told them to imagine throwing a ball. How the brain reacts can indicate if theyíre aware and just canít show it, whatís called locked-in syndrome. But all these tests have drawbacks.

The new work, reported in the journal Science Translational Medicine, aims for an easier, more objective measure. Itís based on the theory that consciousness depends on the complexity of activity in the brain, how well different regions connect and process information. For example, when youíre deeply asleep, the neighborís car alarm may not wake you but your brain still processes that you heard it. When youíre wide awake, it also processes how annoying the alarm is and how often it goes off.

Massiminiís team combined two well-known medical devices. First, a coil delivers a powerful pulse of magnetism that travels through the skull to stimulate the brain, essentially knocking on it to say ďwake up.Ē Then an EEG, which measures brain waves through electrodes attached to the scalp, records the patterns of activity as neurons fire in response.

The final trick: The researchers created a formula to compare the complexity of those resulting brain patterns by ďzippingĒ them, like digital files are compressed so they can be emailed. They called the resulting numerical measurement the PCI, or pertubational complexity index.

The team compared tests from 32 healthy people who were awake, asleep, dreaming or anesthetized, and 20 people with a variety of serious brain injuries. The two patients with locked-in syndrome clearly were aware, scoring nearly as high as awake and healthy people, they reported. The patients diagnosed as being in a vegetative state had scores as low as people rendered unconscious by the most powerful anesthesia. The minimally conscious were somewhere in-between.

The strategy could miss consciousness, so it wouldnít give doctors enough information for end-of-life decisions, researchers caution.


Read the full article at:


RIC: An interesting reader comment in response to the article:
It sounds more like they are measuring the ability to respond to a stimulus rather than consciousness itself.

The hard problem of consciousness is undetermined and therefore unmeasurable.

We all see the color red and know what part of the spectrum triggers it; however, nobody actually knows what gives us that mental image of red and I donít know if your red is the same as mine.
(From: Modern Money Theory Now)

Consciousness : Yes or No?

Get Adobe Flash player

Tune into Red Ice Radio:

Scott Onstott - Hour 1 - Explorations in Number, Architecture & Consciousness

Tom Campbell - The Big TOE (Theory of Everything), Consciousness & Reality

Anthony Peake & Tom Campbell - Consciousness Creates Reality

Anthony Peake - Mystery of the Brain, Precognition, Time Dilation & Dťjŗ vu

Peter Russell - The Primacy of Consciousness

Jim Elvidge - Are we Living in a Simulation, a Programmed Reality?

Paul Levy - The War on Consciousness

Marcel Kuijsten - Julian Jaynes, the Bicameral Mind & The Origin of Consciousness

Graham Hancock - Entangled, Supernatural, Shamanism & The Origins of Consciousness

Related Articles
Will We Ever Understand Consciousness? Scientists and Philosophers Debate
Tom Campbell: Consciousness Is The Computer, Reality Is Information
TED: Non-locality of consciousness is forbidden territory?
The War on Consciousness - Graham Hancockís censored talk at TEDxWhitechapel
The Self: Naturalism, Consciousness, and the First-Person Stance
Ancient Knowledge: Consciousness, Sacred Geometry, Cymatics, Illusion of Reality
The Universal Consciousness - Plants and Animals, Emotions and Pain
Consciousness and All That Jazz
Do these conjoined twins share consciousness?
Signature of consciousness captured in brain scans
Brain scanner íreadsí peopleís dreams - accurately enough to see what they are dreaming about
Secret DARPA Mind Control Project Revealed: Leaked Document
Researchers Try to Improve Math Skills With Electrical Zaps to the Brain

Latest News from our Front Page

Feminist blogger uses her vaginal yeast to make sourdough bread
2015-12-01 22:52
It's a tale that might ensure you never look the same way at a humble loaf again. When a feminist blogger found herself suffering from a vaginal yeast infection, she made the unusual decision to use the unwanted bodily fluid as an ingredient for making bread. Zoe Stavri, who writes under the title Another Angry Woman, has documented the details of her ...
Apple could be working on virtual reality projector, patents show
2015-12-01 22:40
The company has been granted a patent for an ‚Äėadaptive projector‚Äô, which can project images onto surfaces Apple could be working on a new augmented reality projector, which would allow it to make computers without even adding a screen. The company has been granted a patent for an ‚Äúadaptive‚ÄĚ projector, reports Patently Apple. The patents seem to refer to a tool ...
83-year-old Romanian Jewess crowned "Miss Holocaust Survivor" in Israel
2015-12-01 22:23
83-year-old Romanian born Rita Berkowitz wins the one-of-a-kind charity beauty pageant Romania-born woman who immigrated to Israel won the third annual Miss Holocaust Survivors Beauty Pageant in Haifa. Rita Berkowitz, 83, was chosen among the 16 European natives who participated in the contest on Tuesday. She came to Israel in 1951. Hairdressers and makeup artists primped and pampered the contestants before they took ...
North Vancouver schools get first gender-neutral washroom
2015-12-01 21:52
In a first for North Vancouver schools, Seycove secondary has opened a gender-neutral washroom. The move is a step in the right direction and recognition that not every student feels welcome in the binary male- or female-designated washrooms, according to Brian Wilson, president of Seycove’s Queer Straight Alliance Club, which lobbied the school administration for the washroom. High school is already a ...
Newly-Completed Fukushima 'Containment' Wall Already 'Slightly Leaning'
2015-12-01 21:15
Just weeks after re-starting the building of a giant ice-wall to contain groundwater leaking from the Fukushima nuclear plant, TEPCO has been forced to admit that a 780-meter protective wall built alongside the crippled power station (completed only last month and designed to prevent contaminated groundwater from seeping into the sea)  is already "slightly leaning." While this sounds a lot ...
More News »