Repressed Memory - A Cultural Symptom?
By Ashley Pettus | harvardmagazine.com
Are some experiences so horrific that the human brain seals them away, only to recall them years later? The concept of repressed memory, known by the diagnostic term dissociative amnesia, has long fueled controversy in psychiatry. During the 1980s, claims of childhood sexual abuse based on recovered memories led to a spate of highly publicized court cases. A number of the supposed victims retracted their allegations in the early 1990s, admitting that they had been swayed by therapeutic techniques. Yet the scientific validity of dissociative amnesia has remained contested ground.
In a recent study, professor of psychiatry Harrison Pope, co-director of the Biological Psychiatry Lab at Harvard-affiliated McLean Hospital, put repressed memory to the test of time. He reasoned that if dissociative amnesia were an innate capability of the brainakin to depression, hallucinations, anxiety, and dementiait would appear in written works throughout history. In collaboration with associate professor of psychiatry James Hudson, Michael Parker, a professor of English at the U.S. Naval Academy, Michael Poliakoff, director of education programs at the National Endowment for the Humanities, and research assistant Matthew Boynes, Pope set out to find the earliest recorded example of a repressed memory.
The survey yielded various nineteenth-century instances: best known were A Tale of Two Cities (1859), by Charles Dickens, in which Dr. Manette forgets that he is a physician after his incarceration in the Bastille, and Captains Courageous (1896), by Rudyard Kipling, in which Penn, a former minister, loses his memory after his family perishes in a flood and recalls that trauma only after being involved in a collision at sea. But the survey turned up no examples from pre-modern sources.
The researchers then offered a $1,000 rewardposted in three languages on more than 30 Internet websites and discussion groupsto the first person to identify a case of dissociative amnesia in any work of fiction or nonfiction prior to 1800. They received more than 100 responses, but none met the repressed memory criteria. Although many early texts describe ordinary forgetfulness caused by natural biological processes, as well as instances of individuals forgetting happy memories and even their own identities, there were no accounts of an inability to recall a traumatic experience at one point and the subsequent recovery of that memory.
In a report of their findings published in Psychological Medicine, Pope and his colleagues concluded that the absence of dissociative amnesia in works prior to 1800 indicates that the phenomenon is not a natural neurological function, but rather a culture-bound syndrome rooted in the nineteenth century. They argued that dissociative amnesia falls into the diagnostic category pseudo-neurological symptom (or conversion disorder)a condition that lacks a recognizable medical or neurological basis.
The authors have also refuted a number of alternative hypotheses that might explain their survey results. For instance, they argued, the fact that pre-nineteenth- century societies may have conceptualized memory differently than we do cannot account for the lack of recorded descriptions of dissociative amnesia. Our ancestors had little understanding about delusions and hallucinations, Pope points out. They didnt know about dopamine in the brain or things we now know cause paranoia or auditory hallucinations, but descriptions of hallucinations [appear] in literature for hundreds of years and from all over the world. Similarly, If an otherwise lucid individual spontaneously develops complete amnesia for a serious traumatic event, such as being raped or witnessing the death of relations or friends, the researchers explained, a description of such a case would surely be recognizable, even through a dense veil of cultural interpretation such as spirit possession or some other supernatural event.
What, then, accounts for repressed memorys appearance in the nineteenth century and its endurance today? Pope and his colleagues hope to answer these questions in the future. Clearly the rise of Romanticism, at the end of the Enlightenment, created fertile soil for the idea that the mind could expunge a trauma from consciousness, Pope says. He notes that other pseudo-neurological symptoms (such as the female swoon) emerged during this era, but faded relatively quickly. He suspects that two major factors helped solidify repressed memory in the twentieth-century imagination: psychoanalysis (with its theories of the unconscious) and Hollywood. Film is a perfect medium for the idea of repressed memory, he says. Think of the flashback, in which a whole childhood trauma is suddenly recalled. Its an ideal dramatic device.
Shortly after publication of their paper, the investigators awarded the $1,000 prize to the nominator of Nina, an opera by Dalayrac and Marsollier performed in Paris in 1786. (Forgetting that she saw her lover apparently lying dead after a duel, the heroine waits for him daily at an appointed spot. When the young man reappears, Nina first seems to recognize him, then doubts his identity, and only slowly accepts him for who he is.) Pope says he and his colleagues were a few years off their threshold of 1800, but he believes their argument holds: The challenge falls upon anyone who believes that repressed memory is real to explain its absence for thousands of years.
Article from: http://harvardmagazine.com/2008/01/repressed-memory.html
Mind Control Slavery and the New World Order
Monarch Mind Control
History of MK Ultra
Subliminal Advertising and Modern Day Brainwashing
Cyborg Superman, Transhumanism and the Nephilim
The Case Against Dr. Sidney Siemer
The War on Consciousness
The Mind Has No Firewall
Mass Mind Control Through Network Television
Forces of the Unconscious Mind
Latest News from our Front Page
Amid Russia tensions, US nuclear bombers to conduct military drills in Sweden
The Pentagon is planning to send nuclear bombers to Sweden for a military exercise next month amid growing tensions with Russia over the Ukraine crisis.
The warplanes, the B-52 Stratofortress, will participate in a naval exercise on June 13, Swedish general Karl Engelbrektson said.
They are set to fly from the United States nonstop and simulate a drop of anti-ship mines near ...
'Netanyahu to US: Give 50% more money, we'll shut up'
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu is asking the United States to provide Tel Aviv 50 percent more money for weapons and âweâll shut upâ on Iran nuclear talks, an author and investigative journalist in Philadelphia says.
Dave Lindorff made the remarks in a phone interview with Press TV on Wednesday while commenting on a report which says Israel has asked Washington ...
Britain To Outlaw "Hate" and "Extremism"
UK home secretary Theresa May : "But what we're talking about is they key values that underline our society and are being undermined by the extremists. Values like democracy, a belief in democracy, a belief in the rule of law. A belief in tolerance ...eh... for other people. Equality and acceptance for other people's faith and religions.
One of the great ...
Killer robots will leave humans 'utterly defenceless' warns professor
Robots, called LAWS â lethal autonomous weapons systems â will be able to kill without human intervention.
Killer robots which are being developed by the US military âwill leave humans utterly defencelessâ, an academic has warned.
Two programmes commissioned by the US Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency (DARPA) are seeking to create drones which can track and kill targets even when ...
Here's how much corporations paid US senators to fast-track the TPP bill
Critics of the controversial Trans-Pacific Partnership are unlikely to be silenced by an analysis of the flood of money it took to push the pact over its latest hurdle.
A decade in the making, the controversial Trans-Pacific Partnership (TPP) is reaching its climax and as Congress hotly debates the biggest trade deal in a generation, its backers have turned on the ...
|More News » |