Personal Genomes Could Soon Be Public Information
2013 01 21

By Dan Vergano | USAToday.com



Gene detectives ID ’anonymous’ men in registry

Gene detectives identified seemingly anonymous men in a genetic sleuthing study, with about 12% accuracy, using public gene records to triangulate on their last names.

Scientific sleuths identified 12% of "anonymous" men in a genetics registry with publicly available genealogy records. The report raises privacy concerns in an era when more and more genetics data is becoming public.

The registries contain the genomes, or full genetic profiles, of those who volunteered to have their genes analyzed. Since the completion of human genome efforts a decade ago, increasing amounts of such human gene maps have appeared in research registries, even as prices to complete them have fallen to a few thousand dollars. Popular genealogical or ancestry-tracing efforts have also started using genes tied to family names as well, making information about genes that run in particular families public.

"Everyone benefits from more genomic information finding its way into research, offering clues to rare diseases and other ailments," says Yaniv Erlich of the Whitehead Institute for Biomedical Research in Cambridge, Mass., who headed the demonstration effort reported Thursday in the journal, Science. "But we wanted to illuminate the issue of potential privacy issues," he says, not to stop the flood of genomic information helping researchers, but to halt avenues for privacy abuse.

In the study, the team started with men in the international 1000 Genomes Project, an anonymous registry of genomes. They next tied male genes in the registry to the last names of men in publicly available ancestry-tracing sites, finally using age and location information available in the project data to identify about 50 men. Fairly common last names tied to distinct genes in ancestry site records served as the best pointers to the otherwise anonymous project men’s identification. The study does not name them, although a test run did identify genetic luminaries such as human genome pioneer Craig Venter of the J. Craig Venter Institute in Rockville, Md., whose information is online without any disguise.

"In one sense, this is a unique situation," applying only to male genes, says geneticist Martin Bobrow of the United Kingdom’s University of Cambridge, who was not part of the study. "But in another sense, the critical factor is that many people are putting chunks of their personal DNA sequence into databases which are not well secured from public access."

The 2008 Genetic Information Nondiscrimination Act (GINA) federal law bars insurers and employers from discriminating because of genetic tests. And National Institutes of Health (NIH) officials have hidden age information from the "1000 Genomes Project" used in the demonstration, in response to the report released Thursday. Erlich suggests that a combination of better computing ability combined with more and more genetic information raises a need to prevent yet-unforeseen privacy abuses, while preserving the medical and social benefits. In his own lab, for example, Erlich notes such databases have told parents carrying genes for dangerous rare diseases about their fertility risks.

"I would think someone whose privacy alarm bells would be set off by this is already unlikely to be a participant in a study that made their genome data available," says Princeton genome expert Leonid Kruglyak. "But it is something that will need to be noted in informed consent forms," he says, and perhaps considered in non-discrimination law.

"My genome is all out there and I’ve suffered no ill effects," says Venter, who was an adviser to lawmakers behind the 2008 law. "I would actually encourage people to put more of their genetic information online."

Article from: usatoday.com







How the genetics community addresses these issues is crucial to how large-scale genetic studies will proceed. Although research participants are already sometimes told that their data might not remain private — as the CEPH study participants were — the fact that their identities could be revealed would seem a remote risk to them, as that has only recently become possible. It is now imperative that participants fully understand that it is unlikely that their identities can be kept hidden if their genetic data are revealed. Some participants might welcome this, such as those with an interest in genealogy. Others — perhaps those with stigmatized diseases, for instance — might not.

Moving data behind a controlled-access barrier lessens their utility to science and to society at large. But researchers need to show the public that they are acting as careful stewards of the data entrusted to them. Erlich argues that the solution is to make sure that participants understand what they’re signing up for, and to adopt laws that adequately protect people against the misuse of their genetic information.

Geneticists are brainstorming other proposals for balancing data sharing with the need to protect the privacy of research subjects. One is to move more data behind a controlled-access barrier, but to authorize trusted users to access the data from many studies, rather than having to obtain it piecemeal from different studies, as researchers must do today. There are logistical barriers to this — for instance, ensuring compatibility across databases. And it is debatable whether such restrictions might do more harm than good.

But if controlled access is not the right solution, it is up to the research community, in consultation with the public, to devise a better one. A solution should come sooner, rather than later, because this latest revelation of a privacy loophole will be far from the last.
Source: Nature.com




Related Articles
Germany: Facebook must destroy facial recognition database
FBI Wants a Database of Your Tattoos
Oops: Widespread Human DNA Contamination Seen in Genome Databases
New Zealand Widens DNA Database
’Big Brother’ DNA database plan will place innocent people under suspicion for 12 years
US vastly expands its DNA databases
Darpa, Venter Launch Assembly Line for Genetic Engineering
J. Craig Venter Create Synthetic Life - Could it Wipe out Humanity?
Madonna using ’DNA sterilization’ team on tour
DNA of Sandy Hook killer Adam Lanza to be examined for ’evil’ gene in first study of its kind ever conducted on a mass murderer
The US Is Collecting the DNA of World Leaders
Life on Mars? Scientists hope to find it by decoding Martian DNA - ’We Can Rebuild Them’
Loss of Privacy.com
Privacy Is Not Secrecy; Debunking The ’If You’ve Got Nothing To Hide...’ Argument


Latest News from our Front Page

Norway Joins the Race to Develop Killer Robots
2014 10 24
Norway is a large exporter of weapons, which makes the resolution of the debate about creating killer robots an important issue for everyone.  One could debate the overall merits or failings of robotic systems, but an area that clearly has become a point for concern on all sides is the emergence of "killer robots." According to robotics pioneer, David Hanson, ...
Gene That Once Aided Survival in the Arctic Found to Have Negative Impact on Health Today
2014 10 23
In individuals living in the Arctic, researchers have discovered a gene variant that arose thousands of years ago and most likely provided an evolutionary advantage for processing high-fat diets or for surviving in a cold environment; however, the variant also seems to increase the risk of hypoglycemia, or low blood sugar, and infant mortality in today’s northern populations. {snip} “Our work ...
The Ebola hoax: questions, answers, and the false belief in the “One It”
2014 10 23
“The Reality Manufacturing Company doesn’t just sell ‘fake paintings’ that are easy to spot. No. They also sell images that are geared to mesh with people’s deeply held instincts and thereby produce rigid false beliefs. People are sure that if they gave up such beliefs, their world would fall apart and blow away in the wind.” ...
New Controversial Theory Suggests "Hobbits" Were Not Human - Who Were These Mysterious Beings?
2014 10 23
The origin of the Hobbit species remains a challenging subject to scientists. The Hobbit’s discovery confirmed the view that the Earth was once populated by many species of human, but new research the Hobbit’s were not human at all! So, who were these mysterious beings? Where did they come from? The idea that our species, Homo sapiens, was the only species of human on ...
Right into enemy hands? ISIS shows off new weapons allegedly airdropped by US (VIDEO)
2014 10 23
Islamic State has published a new video in which a jihadist shows off brand-new American hardware, which was purportedly intended for the Kurds they are fighting in the Syrian border town of Kobani. The undated video, posted by the unofficial IS mouthpiece “a3maq news”, sees a jihadist showing several boxes of munitions with English-language markings, with a parachute spread out on ...
More News »