In Quebec, infertility is now a disease
2010 07 22

By Margaret Wente | The Globe And Mail

Demographics and politics go hand in hand. And pandering to the baby lobby is just one of the government’s motives

Is infertility a disease? Is access to free in vitro treatment a human right? If you live in Quebec, the answer is yes to both.

Next month, the Quebec government will start funding in vitro fertilization for people who can’t conceive normally. The infertility lobby is ecstatic. So is TV personality Julie Snyder, mother of two adorable in vitro-conceived kids (and wife of one of the province’s richest men, Pierre Karl Péladeau). She’s the poster mom for making fertility treatment an essential service.


“There are some people who can only afford one treatment, so you cry with them,” she said. “It’s deeply unfair. I promised God that if I had my baby I’d do my best to help others.”

It may, indeed, be deeply unfair that Celine Dion can spend a zillion dollars to get pregnant with high-tech twins and you can’t. Yet, millions of us manage to cope. Many things in life are deeply unfair, and infertility is just one of them. And somehow we survive without the government to help us. Meantime, record numbers of people are embracing childlessness out of choice. It seems that one person’s deep unfairness is another’s blessed liberation.

In Quebec, demographics and politics go hand in hand. And pandering to the baby lobby is just one of the government’s motives. The other motive is to bump up the birth rate. The government hopes that all those extra IVF procedures will add another 2,000 babies a year (mostly francophone). And that’s not all. Now that IVF has been deemed a medically necessary service, the government has decreed it will no longer be available privately. Those who wish to pay for it themselves will have to go out of province.

As a result, doctors predict, the system will soon be overwhelmed. “Medicare can’t cope with many areas of medicine,” said Seang Lin Tan, chief obstetrician at the McGill University Health Centre. “The price we pay for free treatments is waiting lists. It will just be more of a burden on the system if we eliminate private treatments.”

Like $8-a-day daycare – Quebec’s last ingenious scheme to boost the birth rate – this one amounts to a blank cheque. The province will cover a wide range of treatments, including three rounds of IVF at $7,000 to $15,000 a pop, and its program will be the most expansive in the world. Single women and lesbian couples will be eligible for free sperm donations. IVF will be offered to people who are already parents, as well as to older women whose natural fertility has fallen off a cliff. By contrast, all other countries that offer IVF impose strict treatment limits. (Germany pays only half the cost.)

By 2014, the new program is expected to cost nearly $70-million. The Health Minister says it will pay for itself because state regulation of IVF will cut down on the number of implanted embryos and, therefore, on the number of multiple and premature births that cost the system millions. This is now the standard argument used by advocates who want other provinces to cover fertility treatments. But critics point out that ovarian stimulation, not IVF, is the main cause of multiple pregnancies. And as the number of IVF pregnancies soars, the cost of IVF-related problems will soar, too. There’s also no new money in the health-care budget to pay for extra nurses, obstetricians and neonatal units.

Many argue that free infertility treatment is a human right. Some are even arguing the case before the Ontario Human Rights Commission. God help us if they win. The trouble is, free treatment costs a lot of money. The burden of Quebec’s expensive new entitlement program will be borne by all those people who really do have diseases. Quebec’s health-care system is already strained to the max and, by international standards, it’s pretty lousy. What about our deep unfairness to them?

Julie Snyder may have kept her promise to God. But let us pray that other provinces don’t cave in.


Article from: theglobeandmail.com



Related Articles
A new method predicts the success of in vitro fertilization
IVF Babies May be More Prone to Childhood Cancers
British fertility clinic raffling human egg
I’ll Have My Cosmetics with a Side of Infertility, Please
Sir David Attenborough calls for UK baby limit to stop ’frightening’ population growth
Baby to be born free of breast cancer after embryo screening


Latest News from our Front Page

Norway Joins the Race to Develop Killer Robots
2014 10 24
Norway is a large exporter of weapons, which makes the resolution of the debate about creating killer robots an important issue for everyone.  One could debate the overall merits or failings of robotic systems, but an area that clearly has become a point for concern on all sides is the emergence of "killer robots." According to robotics pioneer, David Hanson, ...
Gene That Once Aided Survival in the Arctic Found to Have Negative Impact on Health Today
2014 10 23
In individuals living in the Arctic, researchers have discovered a gene variant that arose thousands of years ago and most likely provided an evolutionary advantage for processing high-fat diets or for surviving in a cold environment; however, the variant also seems to increase the risk of hypoglycemia, or low blood sugar, and infant mortality in today’s northern populations. {snip} “Our work ...
The Ebola hoax: questions, answers, and the false belief in the “One It”
2014 10 23
“The Reality Manufacturing Company doesn’t just sell ‘fake paintings’ that are easy to spot. No. They also sell images that are geared to mesh with people’s deeply held instincts and thereby produce rigid false beliefs. People are sure that if they gave up such beliefs, their world would fall apart and blow away in the wind.” ...
New Controversial Theory Suggests "Hobbits" Were Not Human - Who Were These Mysterious Beings?
2014 10 23
The origin of the Hobbit species remains a challenging subject to scientists. The Hobbit’s discovery confirmed the view that the Earth was once populated by many species of human, but new research the Hobbit’s were not human at all! So, who were these mysterious beings? Where did they come from? The idea that our species, Homo sapiens, was the only species of human on ...
Right into enemy hands? ISIS shows off new weapons allegedly airdropped by US (VIDEO)
2014 10 23
Islamic State has published a new video in which a jihadist shows off brand-new American hardware, which was purportedly intended for the Kurds they are fighting in the Syrian border town of Kobani. The undated video, posted by the unofficial IS mouthpiece “a3maq news”, sees a jihadist showing several boxes of munitions with English-language markings, with a parachute spread out on ...
More News »