"World terror watch lists flawed" -Biometrics will 'help tighten up the system'.
2010-01-09 0:00

From: KhaleejTimes.com

Around the world, watch lists are a key tool against terrorism — but highly imperfect.
Experts say simple issues like fickle spelling and incomplete data, as well as deliberate deception and uncooperative countries, all make it possible for a determined terrorist like bomb suspect Umar Farouk Abdulmutallab to slip across borders.

British officials are proud of their list, which contains more than 1 million names, including that of Abdulmutallab. That didn’t stop the young Nigerian boarding a flight from Amsterdam to the United States with explosives in his underwear — a stark reminder of the perils of flawed information-sharing and the limits of watch lists.

“Lists are valuable in making sure governments around the world are able to track individuals,” said John Harrison, an aviation security specialist at Singapore’s S. Rajaratnam School of International Studies. “But you don’t want to put too much emphasis on these lists. It’s an overstatement to say: ‘OK, now we are safe.”’

Analysts say human intelligence, information-sharing and data analysis are also vital to stopping terrorists, and Britain has announced an urgent review of its watch list system in the wake of the Christmas Day attack over Detroit.

The British list holds the names of everyone from suspected terrorists and radical clerics to wanted criminals and rejected visa applicants — like Abdulmutallab, who was added after being denied a student visa in May 2009 for listing the name of a bogus college on the application.

The list is the centerpiece of a program called E-borders, which will eventually check all passengers traveling to or through Britain against the master list. Information comes from police, intelligence services and other sources and is held by the U.K. Border Agency.

Home Secretary Alan Johnson said this week that the list had led to almost 5,000 arrests since 2005 — mostly for crimes such as murder, rape and assault rather than terrorism — and prevented 65,000 people entering Britain in 2009.

“In some countries, there are separate watch lists for security, for policing and crime, for people who have lost their passports and for immigration issues, but an integrated watch list serves us well,” Johnson told lawmakers in the House of Commons.

Magnus Ranstorp, a terrorism expert at the Swedish National Defense College, said the British system was an effective deterrent. In the U.K., he said, every passenger coming into the country is scrutinized.

“Even if you are in transit, and never meet a border guard, it’s a hostile environment if you’re flying through the U.K,” he said.

The list has its limits, though. Names on it are not automatically shared with other countries, although those on a smaller terrorism-related watch list are.

U.S. authorities have said Abdulmutallab was in a database of 500,000 people suspected of terrorist ties, but not on a no-fly watch list. Britain has said it had no indication the Nigerian was planning an attack, and did not flag him to U.S. officials as a particular threat.

On Thursday, Obama announced about a dozen changes designed to fix the system that let Abdulmutallab slip through, including an overhaul of the nation’s terrorist watch lists.

Alain Chouet, former chief of the security intelligence service at France’s counterintelligence agency, estimated that lists he saw when working in intelligence were only about “10 percent viable.”

“The identity of people outside the European tradition is vague. People can change their names, and there is the problem of transcription into European alphabets,” he said.

He used the example of the name Mohamed, which can have different spellings in English, French or Polish.

Even passport numbers are only partially viable since passports can be tampered with, or people can get passports from other countries.

And some countries are more cooperative than others. European Union nations and close allies like the U.S. routinely share information.

“It is outside Europe that we have the problem,” Britain’s Johnson noted this week.

The Home Office declined to name any uncooperative nations, but said biometric data such as fingerprints, which are being introduced on passports and required from all visa holders, would help tighten up the system.

Experts agree that biometrics, which includes physical traits like face recognition, are key to ensuring names on a watch list can be matched to a real individual.

“It’s very difficult to fake, and the governments have begun collecting that information massively,” said Ranstorp.

Around the world there are multiple — and often overlapping — watch lists. In addition to national lists, Interpol established a Terrorism Watch List in April 2002 in response to the Sept. 11, 2001 attacks. The list can be viewed by personnel of the international police agency and by authorized police forces in about 180 countries.

It scored a success in November when authorities in Indonesia were tipped off about Abdul Basir Latip, a suspected al-Qaida-linked militant from the Philippines. Acting on a tip from Interpol, which was sharing information from a U.S. watch list, officials nabbed him Nov. 21 at Jakarta’s international airport. He had arrived from Syria using a fake passport.

This kind of effective coordination is more critical to successful security, analysts said, than the watch lists themselves.

Rolf Tophoven, director of the Germany-based Institute for Terrorism Research and Security Policy, said the bloated U.S. bureaucracy was to blame for intelligence failures in the Christmas Day bombing attempt. Leaner intelligence services have proven much more effective because there is better communication, and information is less likely to fall through the cracks, he said.

“Look at the Israeli intelligence services and their effectiveness countering terrorism and I think you can take one lesson — small but effective,” he said.

Harrison, the aviation security specialist, said Abdulmutallab’s behavior should have set off alarm bells, even if his name on a list did not.

Abdulmutallab apparently bought his ticket in cash, was flying the same day, had no check-in luggage and purchased a one way fare.

Any of those details — and certainly the sum — should have tripped a standard international security procedure, Computer Assisted Passenger Screening or CAPS, Harrison said.

“This case seems more to have been failure, not of lists, but a failure on the human side of intelligence, accurately assessing the threat and tracking the information to see if there were any links,” he said. “It was an analytical failure.”





RedIce Radio:

Charles Farrier - No CCTV, Campaign Against Big Brother Camera Surveillance

Kyle Hunt - The Gods of Technology

Nick Rosen - Going Off-Grid, How to Escape the Big Brother System

Aaron Franz - The Age of Transitions

John Harris - Illusion, Common and Commercial Law & the Ego

Alan Watt - Surveillance, Science & The Grid of Control

Brian Gerrish - Common Purpose & Neuro Linguistic Programming

David Icke - 'Big Brother' By-Election





Related Articles
The Terrorist Watch List reaches 1000665 Names and is still Growing!
Canadian Geese Added to Terror Watch List ;)
Report: FBI Mishandles Terror Watch List
Arms trade: UK dealers accused of selling Soviet weapons to blacklisted countries
Britain's 'least wanted' blacklist published
US 'to blacklist Iranian Guards'
North Korea Removed from US Terror List in Return for Nuclear Inspections
U.S. terrorism watch list tops 1 million
Living off the grid – how to escape the spies all around us
Never Alone: Getting 'off the grid' isn't easy to do
Pioneers Show Americans How To Live "Off-Grid"
Military Industrial Complex Biometric Surveillance Control Grid Revealing Itself
Immigrants Face High-Tech Biometric Scans: UK
FBI Prepares Vast Database Of Biometrics
Zoo to link biometric technology with staff data and payroll
British government introduces biometric data collection
Biometrics gets its ‘fingers’ into school foodservice


Latest News from our Front Page

Sweden may be at war "in a few years" - top brass in leaked document
2016-02-13 5:24
In a few years Sweden may be engaged in a war with a “qualified opponent” after two centuries of peace, a senior Swedish commander has told soldiers in an internal brochure. The alarming message was reportedly sent by Major General Anders Brännström, the Army chief, in a brochure distributed among the participants of a major annual event that is to open ...
Danish imam urges govt to accept child marriages among refugees
2016-02-13 4:57
A high-profile imam has urged the Danish government to accept child brides, as the practice is part of the culture of many refugees arriving in the country. It follows an announcement by Denmark that such couples will be separated under Danish law. Imam Oussama El-Saadi, of the Aarhus mosque in Denmark, said that child brides should be looked at from a ...
White Parents in Virginia Shutdown White Guilt Video!
2016-02-13 4:56
You see folks? This is what happens when you stop blaming the Joo, and you get the fuck off your favorite bitch corner and start taking action! This is what happens when parents start parenting again! What? You’re gonna brainwash our kids with your filth and lies? We don’t think so. How would you like an empty school with no ...
Hungarian Top Economist: Civil War is Coming to Europe
2016-02-13 2:36
Zsolt Bayer, Hungarian journalist, publicist, and co-founder of Hungary's currently ruling political party, and Dr. László Bogár, former politician and leading economist, discuss the Cologne sexual assualts committed by migrants on New Year's Eve, 2016. This short part of the 60-minute long television program that aired on Echo TV on January 8, 2016, is of a rant by Mr. Bogár warning ...
British scientists granted permission to genetically modify human embryos
2016-02-12 23:48
The Francis Crick institute will genetically edit the leftover embryos from from IVF clinics British scientists have been granted permission to genetically modify human embryos by the fertility regulator. The scientists want to deactivate genes in leftover embryos from IVF clinics to see if it hinders development. It will only be the second time in the world that such a procedure has ...
More News »