Carbon Capture Effort Collects Critics
2009-10-23 0:00

By Julio Godoy | IPSNews.com

The capture and underground storage of greenhouse gases, especially carbon dioxide, is a dubious method of effectively reducing the pollution that causes global warming, experts warn.

Scientists, environmentalists and local communities continue to object to the method, which consists of compressing and liquefying carbon dioxide before sending it to underground deposits, and which has been applied for some time to recover petroleum and gas from partially exhausted oil wells.

Left: Schwarze Pumpe, a pilot thermal power plant south of Berlin that uses technology to capture and store carbon emissions.
Credit:Vattenfall


The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) looked at these techniques in 2007, and more closely in 2005, when its Working Group III published a 443-page report.

Germany's federal government was forced last summer to halt the process for approving a law authorising the capture and deposit of carbon, after facing opposition from local communities in the regions preliminarily selected for experimenting with the technique.

Rejection of the process has been fuelled by scientific reports and environmental groups. In 2006, geologist Gabriela von Goerne, of the German branch of Greenpeace, said such methods should only be used as a last option in the fight against global warming.

"The main objective to mitigate climate change should be cutting carbon dioxide emissions at point of origin," von Goerne told Tierramérica. That means a continued reduction in the use of fossil fuels - the main source of carbon dioxide - in human activities.

"By reducing fossil fuel consumption, the demand naturally shifts toward energy sources that don't produce carbon dioxide, like solar, wind and hydro energy," she said.

Instead, the massive capture and storage of carbon would create a stimulus to continue using fossil fuels, and would be an obstacle to the expansion of clean and renewable energy sources.

"Furthermore, it's expensive and consumes a lot of energy, which reduces its efficiency," von Goerne added.

The costs of capturing and storing carbon vary. At electrical plants run on coal or other fossil fuels, capturing and compressing CO2 is relatively simple.

But because the sites planned for storing the carbon are rarely located near the power plants that produce it, it is often necessary to build a pipeline network to carry the liquefied gas from the source to the storage location.

"Just imagining such a pipeline network across Germany is absurd," commented von Goerne.

CO2 can also be extracted from the fuels before combustion, or combustion should take place in an environment into which pure oxygen is injected so that it generates only CO2 and water. In both processes, CO2 has to be compressed and liquefied for transport.

In all cases, capturing the gas itself requires a great deal of energy, reducing the efficiency of the overall process. In 2005, the IPCC estimated that capture and compression of CO2 would increase consumption of fuel at a coal-fired power plant by 25 to 40 percent.

A third argument against this technique is geological: nearly all experts, including operators of test storage sites, agree that storing CO2 can involve gas leaks and cause underground movement, with unpredictable environmental consequences.

A colloquium on carbon capture and storage held in Paris in February, involving French and British experts, included among the difficulties the environmental risks and related problems of acceptance.

It's possible that CO2 leaks at storage sites "could pollute ecosystems and affect human health," Sophie Galharret, of France's Institute of Sustainable Development and International Relations (IDDRI), told Tierramérica.

"Currently it is very difficult to conceive of a way to manage such risks in the public debate to support a widespread application of carbon capture and storage," said Galharret, who participated in the discussions.

The fact that the German government has not approved the law to allow it is just one example of the difficulties the process faces.

Norway, the world's second leading producer of natural gas, supplies 17 percent of European demand and since 1996 has had an experimental CO2 capture and storage system, with storage sites in the North Sea.

According to Brian Bjordal, director of the state-run company Gassco, which coordinates gas distribution from Norway's fields to the rest of Europe, Norway could be compared to a trapeze artist, and the rest of the continent would be the circus audience.

"At the circus, the audience incites the trapeze artist to jump. But if they were in his place, nobody in the audience would jump," Bjordal told Tierramérica, illustrating his own uncertainty about the capture and storage method.

According to IDDRI's Galharret, there is another argument against it: the possibility of failure. And that is linked to a key factor - the pressure of the timeline to reduce greenhouse emissions.

"If the commercial use of carbon capture and storage fails for technical or economic reasons, we won't know until 2015 to 2020. If it fails, Europe would have very little time to readapt its emissions reduction strategies," she said.

Article from: IPSNews.com





Related Articles
Al Gore wants a Global Carbon Tax (Video)
Put carbon tax on babies: academic
British Columbia Introduces Carbon Tax
Ice Cap Alarmists Cherry Pick Science To Fit Carbon Emissions Theory
The World Bank's Carbon Deals
WWF Blames Global Cooling On "Carbon Pollution"
Rothschild Australia and E3 International to take the lead in the global carbon trading market
Carbon trading won't stop climate change
Critics say UK carbon scheme snubs renewable energy
Swedish PM Fredrik Reinfeldt calls for national carbon taxes in Europe
The Climate Bill & ‘Carbon Trading’: Scam of The Century
IDDRI - Carbon Capture and Storage: From Demonstration to Deployment
Iceland Finds New Ways to Trap Carbon
Recapturing Carbon Won't Come Cheap (2007)


Latest News from our Front Page

Austria, Libya count dead as number of migrants crossing Mediterranean soars
2015-08-29 1:37
Austria said on Friday 71 refugees including a baby girl were found dead in an abandoned freezer truck, while Libya recovered the bodies of 82 migrants washed ashore after their overcrowded boat sank on its way to Europe and scores more were feared dead. The U.N. refugee agency said the number of refugees and migrants crossing the Mediterranean to reach Europe ...
Financial Times Calls For Abolishing Cash
2015-08-29 1:07
liminating physical currency necessary to give central banks more power The Financial Times has published an anonymous article which calls for the abolition of cash in order to give central banks and governments more power. Entitled The case for retiring another ‘barbarous relic’, the article laments the fact that people are stockpiling cash in anticipation of another economic collapse, a factor which ...
Serbian government bans anti-mass immigration protests, and plans ahead for mass immigration
2015-08-29 1:52
Nebojsa Stefanovic, Serbia’s Interior Minister said protesters who are concerned about “an EU plan” to settle thousands of illegal immigrants into the country, will not be allowed to voice their concerns in a protest march on Monday, 31st of August. “We will not allow the expression of intolerance and hatred to be something that is characteristic of Serbia” said Stefanovic. “The Ministry ...
Germany asks Facebook to remove 'racist' anti-migrant posts
2015-08-28 20:32
Heiko Maas, Germany's justice minister, says social network should remove xenophobic posts in the same way it deals with nudity Germany is calling on Facebook to remove “xenophobic and racist” anti-migrant posts from its website and apps. Heiko Maas, the German justice minister, has written to the company to demand an urgent review of its policy over hate messages. “Photos of certain ...
Virginia TV Shooter Said, "Jehovah Spoke To Me That I Should Take Action"
2015-08-28 2:36
What causes a guy to go off the plantation enough so that he would murder in cold blood, two of his former colleagues? Guesses are abounding, such as racial tension, mental illness, psychotropic prescription drugs, narcissism, etc. What about the angle of how a destructive religious cult shaped him in his formative years, so that later in life, he would ...
More News »