The Long Data of European Jewish Expulsions
2013 09 21

By Samuel Arbesman | wired.com


As you might have realized, I love datasets of long timescale, ones that talk about Long Data. Well, here’s a doozy of a dataset: 700 years of European Jewish persecutions and expulsions. Forming the basis for a thought-provoking paper on SSRN titled “From the Persecuting to the Protective State? Jewish Expulsions and Weather Shocks from 1100 to 1800“—it explores whether there is a relationship between weather and growing season and the likelihood that the Jewish community would be expelled—is this incredibly detailed dataset culled from the Encyclopaedia Judaica. From the paper (further details about how the dataset was compiled are available in the appendix):
We collect city–level data on the presence of a Jewish community in Europe between 1100 to 1800 from the twenty-six volume Encyclopedia Judaica (2007). The Encyclopedia typically mentions when Jews entered a city, when they were persecuted, when they were expelled, and when they were allowed re-entry. We are interested in all of these pieces of information since in order to model the probability of an expulsion from a city, we need to know when that city had a Jewish population to expel.

The Encyclopedia provides a comprehensive measure of Jewish presence, persecution and expulsion for the whole of Europe. It does not contain information on all of the smaller Jewish communities that may have existed and it likely does not contain information on minor persecutions. Voigtländer and Voth (2012) uses more detailed data for Jewish persecutions in medieval Germany. But the two sources they employ only provide data for Germany. The Encyclopedia Judaica provides less detail but compensates for this with wider geographic and temporal coverage.
Here is a visualization of this unbelievable dataset:



The paper also includes a detailed discussion of Jewish persecution and expulsion in Medieval Europe:
It is important not to overstate the frequency with which Jewish communities were threatened with violence and pogroms—many Jewish communities lived in peace with their Christian neighbors for long periods of time. But as an economically dominant minority in poor and largely agrarian economies, and as outsiders in a society that increasingly aggressively defined itself in opposition to infidels and unbelievers, Jews often aroused jealousy and suspicion from others.
While the discussion is much more involved, here is a time series of these expulsions (along with temperature data), which highlights certain historical events and gives a sense of the expulsion frequency:



Unfortunately, the dataset doesn’t seem to be currently publicly available but I would love to see what further insights can be gleaned from this long data.

This article is written by By Samuel Arbesman for wired.com

Ed Comment: So yet another problem of global warming (and cooling) is pinpointed. Yes, it’s simply the weather’s fault! ; ) That is what drove those grumpy irrational "agrarian" medieval country bumpkin Europeans stir crazy! Glad that this mystery is sorted out then.



Related Articles
109 Locations whence Jews have been Expelled since AD250
First ever European Jewish Parliament inaugurated in Brussels
Jewish Extremists Elect "Jews-Only" Parliament
Once is happenstance. Twice is coincidence. Three times is enemy action


Latest News from our Front Page

Chess-playing computers may cause the robot apocalypse
2014 04 23
Sore-loser chess programs might be the end of us all... In the movie The Terminator, we heard the human side of the story of Judgment Day, with the machines getting smart and seeing us as a threat. It wasn’t until the sequel that we heard the tale from the machine’s point of view, as it chose to start World War III ...
Archeologists’ findings may prove Rome a century older than thought
2014 04 23
It is already known as the eternal city, and if new archeological findings prove correct Rome may turn out to be even more so than believed until now. Next week, the city will celebrate its official, 2,767th birthday. According to a tradition going back to classic times, the brothers Romulus and Remus founded the city on 21 April in the year ...
Swedish MP ordered chemtrail probe
2014 04 23
A Swedish MP who launched an official government investigation into the existence of chemtrails tells The Local why he thinks Swedes deserve the truth, even if it may leave some conspiracy theorists unsatisfied. "I can’t speak for other MPs, but I’ve had many, many calls over the past eight years about chemtrails. And these questions are not so easy to answer," ...
Mystery of Bizarre Duck-Like Ocean Sound
2014 04 23
If it quacks like a duck... it’s not always a duck. Scientists have reportedly gotten to the bottom of the mysterious ’Bio-Duck’ sound in the Antarctic. Here’s a recording of the strange sound (it’s kind of a stretch to say it sounds like a duck, but who are we to second guess the biologists?). --- Mystery of Bizarre Duck-Like Ocean Sound Solved By Tanya Lewis ...
’Extreme’ Carbon Dioxide Reduction will be a Death Sentence for Humanity & Planet Earth
2014 04 23
If we allow a fraudulent pseudo-environmentalist cult to control every aspect of our lives then our children are doomed to a totalitarian existence which Stalin could only have dreamed of. “The common enemy of humanity is man. In searching for a new enemy to unite us, we came up with the idea that pollution, the threat of global warming, water shortages, famine ...
More News »