Calling Tsarnaev an ’enemy combatant’ creates a vicious double standard
2013 04 30

By Jill Filipovic | The Guardian

Eric Rudolph, the anti-abortion bigot behind the 1996 Atlanta bombing, was tried as a criminal. What makes Boston different?

When is a violent attacker a terrorist, an enemy combatant or a criminal? To some hawkish Republicans, the answer appears to depend more on a suspect’s religion than his actions or affiliations.


Eric Rudolph (in 2003), who is serving a life sentence for the 1996 attack on the Olympic Park in Atlanta that killed one and injured 111 – an attack that has been compared to the Boston Marathon bombing.

Dzhokhar Tsarnaev, the younger of the Boston bombers, is the latest example. In allegedly carrying out the bombing at the Boston marathon, Tsarnaev and his older brother appear to have acted alone. At time of writing, there is no suggestion that they were affiliated with any terrorist cell or organization, let alone the army of a foreign nation. The motives behind the bombing remain unclear, but even if the surviving Tsarnaev does go on to justify the attack with religion or anti-Americanism, that doesn’t meet even the intentionally loose, disturbingly Orwellian definition of "enemy combatant" outlined post-9/11 by the Bush administration.

Given these facts, the White House made the common sense (and legally tenable) decision to try Tsarnaev in criminal court as a civilian. But some Republican legislators aren’t content with using our justice system – they want Tsarnaev to be designated an "enemy combatant", against all the available evidence.

Senator Lindsey Graham, for example, recognizes that Tsarnaev couldn’t reasonably be tried by a military tribunal, but says the administration should deem him an enemy combatant nonetheless, for intelligence-gathering purposes. To clarify Senator Graham’s point: he’s advocating against the basic constitutional protections that the United States affords individuals accused of crimes. Doing so displays not just a disturbing level of cynicism and bigotry, but a shameful lack of respect for the American justice system and the US constitution.

Our criminal justice system is vastly imperfect. We incarcerate more people than any nation in the history of the world, and we dole out sentences that are longer and harsher than they would be in many other countries. We’ve privatized the building of prisons, incentivizing more incarcerations. Our solitary confinement practices and our collective refusal to do anything about prison rape often means that incarceration crosses the line into torture.

[...]

The American criminal justice system has proven time and again that it is fully capable of trying domestic terrorists. There’s little difference between the acts allegedly carried out by the Boston Marathon bombers and those committed by Eric Rudolph, the rightwing Olympic Park bomber. It’s only the religion of the bombers that seems to be motivating the very different political responses.

Read the full article at: guardian.co.uk




Related Articles
Senator Lindsey Graham Says Suspend the Constitution For Boston Marathon Suspect


Latest News from our Front Page

Horrifying accidents at infectious disease labs hidden from the public, ‘cloaked in secrecy’
2014 08 26
Literally hundreds of incidents involving viruses, bacteria and toxins that pose major bioterror risks to both people and agriculture have been reported to federal regulators from 2008 through 2012, according to government reports obtained and reviewed by USA Today. More than half of the over 1,100 incidents were serious enough that laboratory workers had to have medical evaluations and/or treatment, the ...
Those Who Know They’re Dreaming Are Savvier When Awake
2014 08 26
It’s probably fair to assume that at this moment, you are, in fact, awake. You’re reading; you’re scrolling; sometime in the not-too-distant past, you somehow made your way to The Atlantic’s website. All waking activities. But let’s say, hypothetically, that as you’re reading this, the floor and everything else beneath you dissolve, leaving your body floating where your chair had been ...
Kiev’s bloody eastern Ukraine campaign
2014 08 26
Russia delivered humanitarian aid to the besieged city of Lugansk as fighting between the Ukrainian army and self-defense forces continues in eastern Ukraine. The conflict has claimed the lives of at least 2,000 people and displaced over 300,000. VIDEO: Ukraine: Russian aid handed out in Lugansk Tuesday, August 26 15:25 GMT: The latest UN figures show that the number of killed and wounded ...
History Repeats: Dead Blondes on a Mountain Top
2014 08 26
The blonds of Iraq; hunted like dogs to the top of a mountain. The shocking headline from the August 14 London Daily Mail declared: ’ISIS want to impregnate Yazidi women and smash our blond bloodline’: Fears grow for the 300 women kidnapped from Sinjar’ The Yazidi minority of Iraq is of Aryan descent (like most Europeans) and has retained much of its ...
Naturally High Fluoride Levels in Private Wells May Be Linked With IQ Decline
2014 08 26
Certain kinds of granite contain high levels of fluoride, increasing the concentration in private wells drawing it from the water. Newly available data, released in recent months, indicates dangerously high levels of fluoride in private wells. In some cases, the wells contain more than double the level that the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency has deemed the acceptable maximum exposure level ...
More News »