CIA demands cuts to critical 9/11 memoir
2011 08 31

By Dan De Luce | Google.com / AFP

The Central Intelligence Agency has demanded a publisher make extensive cuts to a book critical of its performance before and after the September 11 attacks, officials said Friday.

"The Black Banners: The Inside Story of 9/11 and the War Against Al-Qaeda," a memoir by former FBI agent Ali Soufan due out next month, recounts his experiences at the heart of high-profile terror investigations.

Soufan has accused the CIA of insisting on scores of redactions he says are not justified on security grounds but are aimed at undermining an account that reflects badly on the agency, the New York Times reported.

A spokesman for the CIA rejected the accusation and said the changes were meant to safeguard national security.

"The suggestion that the Central Intelligence Agency has requested redactions on this publication because it doesn’t like the content is ridiculous," CIA spokesman Preston Golson said in an email.

"The CIA’s pre-publication review process looks solely at the issue of whether information is classified," he said.

In his book, Soufan reportedly argues that the CIA botched an opportunity to prevent the 2001 terror plot by failing to divulge information to the FBI about two future 9/11 hijackers based in San Diego.

He is also critical of the harsh interrogation techniques used on terror suspects -- including Abu Zubaydah, the first important captive taken after the 9/11 attacks -- saying such methods are counterproductive.

The dispute over the book comes as the country prepares to mark the 10th anniversary of the September 11 attacks on New York and Washington and amid a continuing debate about the treatment of terror suspects.

In a 78-page letter, the CIA requested a range of cuts to the manuscript, including of information already made public or discussed at congressional hearings, according to WW Norton and Company, the book’s publisher.

With the memoir due to go on sale in less than a month, the company said it plans to publish the book with the edits demanded by the CIA.

"Norton will publish the book with redactions," Louise Brockett, a Norton spokeswoman, told AFP.

The author, quoted in the New York Times, criticized the CIA for its approach and said the government needed to face honestly "where we made mistakes and let the American people down."

"It saddens me that some are refusing to address past mistakes."

Golson countered that "just because something is in the public domain doesn’t mean it’s been officially released or declassified by the US government."

A US official argued that Soufan was not being silenced in any way and has often spoken out publicly.

"No one’s stopped Ali Soufan from expressing his opinions about the interrogation of terrorists. He’s done it repeatedly, in several media outlets," said the official, who spoke on condition of anonymity.

The changes demanded by the CIA include wording used by Soufan in 2009 testimony at a Senate hearing and references to the agency’s "stations," the widely used, traditional word for CIA offices abroad.
Soufan is not the first author to face tough restrictions by the CIA, according to Steven Aftergood, who leads the Project on Government Secrecy for the Federation of American Scientists.

The "CIA has often been very heavy-handed in its pre-publication review process, sometimes including restrictions on information that is already in the public domain," he said.

"The CIA thinks the national security of the United States is so fragile that it can be damaged by repeating the wrong words. But others believe that free expression and robust debate are exactly what make the nation strong."


Article from: google.com




Ed Note: While publication bans and redaction are business as usual for the CIA, this feels like a distraction.
The question is not ’was there an intelligence failure’ - the question is ’how big was it, who was involved, and why was it allowed to happen’?
Calling the intelligence and communication botches "mistakes" gives the CIA a pass. These "mistakes" very well could have been purposeful misdirections, assists, and cover-ups within the agency so as to accomplish the events of 9/11.

~E





Related Articles
NYPD Is Working With (Spying With) CIA To "Fight Terror"
Syrian Regime´s Repression Greatly Magnified By The Only Source of Western Media - the CIA
Declassified CIA Documents Reveal Details of Bay of Pigs Invasion
Insider: CIA Orchestrated Operation Fast and Furious
Timing of US drone strike questioned: "It was in retaliation for Davis.The CIA was angry."
Dept. of Defense buys 9,500 copies of book - then burns them
Google Patents Censorship Of ‘Annoying’ Content
Government Nanny Censoring "Conspiracy Theories" is Also Responsible for Letting Bush Era Torture and Spying Conspiracies Go Unpunished
Chile: trapped miners get Brad Pitt, censored news (Funny, that’s what we get too)
How Press Censorship Hid the Shocking Truth About Nagasaki A-Bomb 65 Years Ago


Latest News from our Front Page

Mad Science: ‘Genetically Modified Micro Humans’ to be ‘Farmed’ for Drug Testing by 2017
2014 09 12
Developers of artificial micro-humans, or ‘mini GM humans,’ are hoping to release their technology on the market by 2017. No this isn’t a sci-fi joke. Scientists are developing artificial humans in the same vein as GM plants with the hope that these creations will replace the need for using animals in laboratory testing. Artificial humans will be ‘farmed’ with interacting ...
Friends of Rape: How Feminist Liberals Help Sex-Crime to Flourish
2014 09 12
Deafeningly. That’s how liberals would have reacted if the victims in Rotherham had been Pakistani, the rapists White and the cover-up organized by the Conservative party and its allies in the right-wing media. If the scandal had been like that, the Guardian would have boiled with righteous wrath and indignation: “The horror of it. At least 1,400 victims subject to ...
How NASA Plans to Open ’Air Highways’ for Drones
2014 09 10
If Amazon and Google are going to take their drone delivery operations public, what’s going to ensure they do it safely? Air highways and specialized drone corridors designed by NASA scientists, apparently. Even if the Federal Administration Administration isn’t sold on the idea of commercial drones flying throughout the country, NASA is. The agency has quietly been working on an air ...
Ancient Egyptians documented animal extinctions
2014 09 10
"What was once a rich and diverse mammalian community is very different now," the study’s lead author Justin Yeakel said. Some six millennia ago, 37 species of large-bodied mammals roamed the deserts and river valleys of modern Egypt. Today, there are only eight. And as new research shows, ancient Egyptian art has helped tell the story of ecological loss in North ...
Internet Payment Network Paypal To Start Accepting Bitcoin
2014 09 09
EBay Inc. (EBAY)’s PayPal service will start accepting bitcoins, opening up the world’s second-biggest Internet payment network to virtual currency transactions. “We’re announcing PayPal’s first foray into bitcoin,” Bill Ready, the chief of EBay’s Braintree unit, said at Techcrunch’s Disrupt SF conference yesterday. “Over the coming months we’ll allow our merchants to accept bitcoin. On the consumer side it will be ...
More News »