Earth-like planet ’may not exist’: Goldilocks just a fairytale?
2010 10 18

By Niall Firth | DailyMail.co.uk



Its discovery last month captured the imaginations of millions around the globe.

And the news that an Earth-like planet had been found which could support life and which lay only 20 light years away sparked feverish speculation that we may not be alone in the universe.

But now a group of scientists have claimed that Gliese 581g, a rocky world just three times the size of Earth, may not even exist.

The devastating claim has been made by a group of Swiss astronomers who have cast doubt on the original research and say that they can find no trace of the planet in their own analysis of the same data.


This artist’s conception shows the inner four planets of the Gliese 581 system and their host star, a red dwarf star only 20 light years away from Earth. The four tiny planets in the background are the planets that have already been discovered. The closer, blue and green planet is 581G, the most Earth-like planet ever discovered.

In the original announcement last month a team led by Dr Stephen Vogt from the University of California said that Gliese 581g lay in its star’s ’Goldilocks zone’ - the region in space where conditions are neither too hot or too cold for liquid water to form oceans, lakes and rivers.

Planets orbiting distant stars are too small to be seen by telescopes. Instead, astronomers look for tell-tale gravitational wobbles in the stars that show a planet is in orbit.

But Francesco Pepe of the Geneva Observatory in Sauverny, Switzerland, told a conference in Torino, Italy, that a combination of old and new data acquired by his team shows no sign of the planet.

Pepe said: ’If a signal corresponding to the announced Gliese 581g planet was present in our data we should have been able to detect it.’

His team had access to the same sets of data that the original researchers who trumpeted the existence of the planet to worldwide fanfare at the end of September.

Those measurements revealed a total of four planets circling the star. The team’s latest report also includes an additional 60 measurements made with the sensitive HARPS spectrograph on a telescope at La Silla, Chile.

They discovered the existence of the four planets circling Gliese 581, which had already been confirmed, but could find no sign of Gliese 581g - the planet which had gripped the public’s imagination.

Pepe told the conference: ’From these data we easily recover the four previously announced planets. However, we do not see any evidence for a fifth planet in an orbit of 37 days’.

He told New Scientist that he was not trying to undermine Dr Steven Vogt who led the original study at the University of California, Santa Cruz.
’We are not trying to prove the nonexistence of a planet,’ Pepe said. ’It’s really difficult to prove that something does not exist. We are just saying we do not see a significant signal that is really different from noise.’

Steven Vogt, who did not attend the meeting in Turin, told New Scientist said that HIRES data – which were not used by the Geneva team – were needed in order to see the planet.


The orbits of planets in the Gliese 581 system are compared to those of our own solar system. The Gliese 581 star has about 30% the mass of our sun, and the outermost planet is closer to its star than we are to the sun. The 4th planet, G, is a planet that could sustain life.

He told the magazine: ’I feel confident that we have accurately and honestly reported our uncertainties and done a thorough and responsible job extracting what information this data set has to offer.’

He added: ’In 15 years of exoplanet hunting, with over hundreds of planets detected by our team, we have yet to publish a single false claim, retraction, or erratum.’

The Swiss team has not yet published its results in a peer-reviewed journal - crucial if its doubts are to be taken seriously by the scientific community.
Last month researchers said that the discovery of Gliese 581g suggested the universe is teeming with world like our own.

If it exists, it is so far away, spaceships travelling close to the speed of light would take 20 years to make the journey. If a rocket was one day able to travel at a tenth of the speed of light, it would take 200 years to make the journey.

The findings come from 11 years of observations at the W. M. Keck Observatory in Hawaii.

The planet orbits a small red star called Gliese 581 in the constellation of Libra. The planet, named Glieseg, is 118,000,000,000,000 miles away - so far away that light from its start takes 20 years to reach the Earth.

It takes just 37 days to orbit its sun which means its seasons last for just a few days. One side of the planet always faces its star and basks in perpetual daylight, while the other is in perpetual darkness.

The most suitable place for life or future human colonists would be in the ’grey’ zone - the band between darkness and light that circles the planet.
’Any emerging life forms would have a wide range of stable climates to choose from and to evolve around, depending on their longitude,’ said Dr Vogt who reported the find in the Astrophysical Journal.

Astronomers have now found six planets in orbit around Gliese 581 - including the no-disputed ’g’ - the most discovered in a planetary system other than our own solar system.

Its star is a red giant - a massive star near the end of its life. It is too dim to see in the night sky from Earth without a telescope.

Astronomers have found nearly 500 exoplanets - or planets outside our own solar system.

However, almost all are too big, made of gas instead of rock, too hot or too cold for life as we know it.


Article from: dailymail.co.uk



Ed Note: So, they discovered the planet, assured us it would contain "life", detected strange light pulses coming from it, and now it doesn’t exist? Hmmm....

~E







Related Articles
Could ’Goldilocks’ planet be just right for life?
Mysterious Light Pulse From Planet Gliese 581g - Alien Signal?
A Million Questions About Habitable Planet Gliese 581g
Odds of Life on Newfound Earth-Size Planet ’100 Percent,’ Astronomer Says (Approaching disclosure?)
Did planet hunter leak data about other Earths?
Can Planet X Nibiru Support Life? (Video)
Scientists discover Earth-like, water-rich planet: study
Hello from Earth: Send a Message to a Nearby Planet


Latest News from our Front Page

EU on high alert as Germany accepts Ebola patients
2014 07 30
A German hospital has agreed to treat Ebola patients amid widespread fears of a possible outbreak of the deadly disease in Europe. Over 670 people have already been killed by the disease in West Africa with doctors struggling to control the epidemic. A German hospital in Hamburg agreed to accept patients following a request from the World Health Organization (WHO), Deutsche ...
Bolivia declares Israel terrorist regime
2014 07 30
Bolivia has declared Israel a “terrorist state” and revoked a visa exemption agreement with Tel Aviv in protest at the ongoing Israeli attacks on the besieged Gaza Strip. The move "means, in other words, we are declaring (Israel) a terrorist state," President Evo Morales said during talks with a group of educators in the city of Cochabamba ...
Pagan Traditions: Mysteries of medieval graffiti in England’s churches
2014 07 30
Medieval graffiti of straw kings, pentagrams, crosses, ships and "demon traps" have been offering a tantalising glimpse into England’s past. What do the pictures reveal about life in the Middle Ages? A project to record the graffiti, which began in Norfolk, has now been rolled out to other areas and is gradually spreading across England. Armed with just a torch and a ...
More Gigantic Holes Appear in Siberia’s ’End of the World’
2014 07 30
Is it the end of the world in Siberia’s ’End of the World’? Scientists suspect not, but they’re still investigating the strange and alarming holes that are swallowing up the Siberian north. This week two new holes have been discovered, and with similar characteristics as the first reported hole: a very deep shaft with smooth sides, debris surrounding the rim, and water ...
BLACKLISTED: The Secret Government Rulebook For Labeling You a Terrorist
2014 07 30
The Obama administration has quietly approved a substantial expansion of the terrorist watchlist system, authorizing a secret process that requires neither “concrete facts” nor “irrefutable evidence” to designate an American or foreigner as a terrorist, according to a key government document obtained by The Intercept. The “March 2013 Watchlisting Guidance,” a 166-page document issued last year by the National Counterterrorism Center, ...
More News »