BP digitally alters press photo, confesses itís a fake
By Wilson Rothman | MSNBC.MSN.com
Itís been a long season of embarrassment for BP, but leaking oil isnít what the blogosphere is ripping the company for today. A site called Americablog spotted a press photo of BPís Houston command center, ostensibly taken on July 16. The image had quite visibly been Photoshopped ó badly ó to include more on-screen camera action.
Once word got out ó the story was picked up by the Washington Post, where it was then spotted by the tech blog Gizmodo and others ó BP ífessed up. A spokesman admitted that the image was altered, said that a photographer had inserted shots where the TV screens were blank, and provided the original image.
"Weíve instructed our post-production team to refrain from doing this in the future," said the spokesman in an e-mail to the Washington Post.
Though the command center alteration doesnít seem to be an attempt to hide facts or confuse the public, it heightens skepticism for the company at a time when it should be trying to build trust. As the Americablog reporter John Aravosis wrote, "I guess if youíre doing fake crisis response, you might as well fake a photo of the crisis response center."
As it happens, the command center shot isnít the end of the issue. Today, Aravosis published evidence of another altered press photo, this one depicting a meeting from the failed "top kill" maneuver. "How many other crisis response photos from BP have been faked?" wrote Aravosis. "Did they fake any videos?"
Please donít tell us that the people in those sucking-it-up-and-taking-responsibilty ads are actually paid models!
Article from: msnbc.msn.com
Why Would BP Photoshop Its Crisis Command Center?
By Carl Franzen | AOLNews.com
BPís public image problems took a turn for the weirder on Monday, with AMERICAblogís John Aravosis exposing a poorly doctored photo of the companyís crisis command center in Houston that had been posted to the official crisis response website. The company has now come clean (sort of) to The Washington Post -- claiming this morning that it was the photographer who snapped the image who was responsible for inserting three extra video screens into a bank of monitors. It still remains unclear, though, precisely why the alterations were even made in the first place.
Check out the differences for yourself. First up, the Photoshopped image as it originally appeared on BPís website:
HIVE at Houston Command Center, July 16, 2010. (BP LLC) ALTERED IMAGE
Next, the updated image posted last night, purportedly unaltered, which shows three blank ROV screens in place of the underwater images that had been pasted into the original photo.
HIVE at Houston Command Center, July 16, 2010. (BP LLC) ORIGINAL IMAGE
"Normally, we only use Photoshop for the typical purposes of color correction and cropping," BP spokesman Scott Dean told the Post in an e-mail. "In this case, they copied and pasted three ROV screen images in the original photo over three screens that were not running video feeds at the time."
BPís remote-operated vehicles (ROVs), or robot submarines, have played crucial roles in the response to the gulf oil spill crisis since it began, sending back video and still images of the scene around the well and operating the various proposed mechanical solutions for containing the leak a mile below the surface, where no human divers can work.
However, BP has been criticized for suppressing damning underwater video footage from the public -- specifically, footage that showed much more serious leaks than the company was admitting to during the days immediately following the Deepwater Horizon platform explosion on April 20.
In this case, the company, or someone employed by it, seems to have made the opposite error -- supplying extra views where there were none. Why would BP or the photographer do so? Bloggers have proposed several theories.
1. The Photo Was Too Old
As one of AMERICABlogís readers pointed out, "The photo contains data suggesting it was taken in 2001, not July of 2010 as claimed on BPís website. That would suggest at least one possibility is that BP took an old photo and Photoshopped new pictures of the oil spill over it, to make it look ínew.í" The company has not addressed this speculation, and the meta data for the updated photo contains a time stamp from July 16.
2. BP Feared the Blogosphere
Gawkerís Max Read wonders if BP was hoping to avoid further public criticism for posting a photo showing blank video screens. "Were they so afraid of the withering comments of bloggers noticing three blank screens that they thought they should paste in three duplicate images?" If so, the mission failed.
3. BP Just Doesnít Care
EnergyBoomís Nathanael Baker offers one of the most cynical interpretations yet, saying that the faked photo is just further evidence of the companyís unrepentant audacity. "With all the public scrutiny surrounding BP, it is absolutely amazing that the company not only continues to make such poor public relations decisions, but also continues to offer misinformation to the world."
4. BP Responds: Combination of Good Intentions Gone Bad, Technical Glitches
UPDATED: BP spokesperson Scott Dean told Surge Desk that the photo was altered in post-production by the photographer and a team of editors, to make the scene "more panoramic," but that it was a mistake and that the company has not and will not be doing any similar adjustments.
When asked if there are other photos currently on the website that have undergone similar Photoshop treatments, Dean said that "some have undergone color-correction and cropping, but thatís generally the extent. Weíre currently looking through and reviewing all of the other photos to make sure nothing like this has happened anywhere else. Itís certainly not a routine practice."
Read the full article at: AOLNews.com
BP canít photoshop the truth (Video)
Amid leak worries, feds and BP focus on killing Gulf well
BP officials aboard Deepwater Horizon to testify
Matt Simmons (Member of CFR, Club of Rome & Peak Oil Proponent) Says: BP Covering Up Massive Leaking Hole Miles Away
Former BP Contractor Turned Whistleblower Talks
Cop Bullies Videographer as She Videos a BP Worker Taken Away in Ambulance
The BP AD - First the Propaganda Version, Then The Uncensored Version
ProPublica Photographer Detained By Law Enforcement At The Behest Of BP
Facebook has Deleted "Boycott BP" with 800,000 Fans
BP: The Criminal in Control of Crime Scene
Latest News from our Front Page
Anglo-Saxon Sword and Helmet from Staffordshire Hoard Reconstructed
Thousands of metal fragments from the Staffordshire Hoard have been reconstructed into two "significant" new 7th Century objects.
Researchers have pieced together parts of a silver helmet and a previously unseen form of sword pommel.
The hoard, which is valued at ¬£3.2m, was found in a field near Burntwood, Staffordshire in July 2009.
Both items have been put on display at Birmingham's Museum ...
ALEC corruption: Legislators and corporate lobbyists meet in secret at Savannah resort
The Georgia Legislature has a message for voters: don't ask us about our meetings with corporate lobbyists behind closed doors.
The 11Alive Investigators tracked lawmakers to a resort hotel in Savannah last week, where we observed state legislators and lobbyists mingling in the hotel bar the night before they gathered in private rooms to decide what new laws would best serve ...
Swedish politician: US is the true cause of the masses of refugees from the Middle East
Editors Note: And who controls US foreign policy? Listen to Jeff Gates.
The present Swedish debate about war refugees from the Middle East is an example of peer restricted expression. In the name of political correctness or perceived decency, any questioning of maximum generosity in opening Swedish borders for the refugees is indignantly rejected by the official mainstream. We have a ...
Even if Patriot Act Expires, Government Will Keep Spying on All Americans
Government Will Use "Secret Interpretations" to Get Around Legal Prohibitions
Mass surveillance under the Patriot Act is so awful that even its author says that the NSA has gone far beyond what the Act intended (and that the intelligence chiefs who said Americans aren't being spied on should be prosecuted for perjury).
Specifically, the government is using a "secret interpretation" of the ...
The TPP, Monsanto, Rockefeller, Trilateral Commission, Brzezinski
All hands on deck for global, economic, corporate dictatorship
There are dots to connect here. They're real, and they're spectacular.
Let me begin with a brief exchange from a 1978 interview, conducted by reporter Jeremiah Novak. He was speaking with two American members of the Trilateral Commission (TC), a group founded in 1973 by David Rockefeller and his intellectual flunkey, Zbigniew Brzezinski.
|More News » |