Doubt cast on Noahs ark found in Turkey
2010-05-02 0:00

By Stephen Kurczy | CSMonitor.com

A group of Chinese and Turkish explorers announced this week they are 99.9 percent sure of their discovery on Mt. Ararat. While Noahs ark found in Turkey would bolster Bible literalists, an American ark-hunter says the latest discovery could be a hoax.


Ark of Noah on Mount Ararat. Attributed to Hieronymus Bosch.
1500-1504 Rotterdam, Museum Boymans - van Beuningenaaa

A longtime ark-hunter has serious doubts about this weeks announcement that Noahs ark was found in eastern Turkey.

A Chinese-Turkish team from Noahs Ark Ministries International held a press conference April 25 in Hong Kong to present their findings and say they were 99 percent sure that pieces of wood found at above 12,000-feet elevation and dated as 4,800 years old were from the biblical Noahs ark.

Such a finding would provide evidence for a literal interpretation of the Bible and boost the evangelical Christian worldview in a relatively young Earth that was formed in seven days and where a wrathful God punishes the wicked.

But Dr. Randall Price, an evangelical Christian and former member of the Chinese-led team that announced this weeks finding, says the latest purported finding may not withstand closer scrutiny.

"If the world wants to think this is a wonderful discovery, thats fine. My problem is that, in the end, proper analysis may show this to be a hoax and negatively reflect how gullible Christians can be," he says.


A picture taken in 2004 shows the Mount Ararat. A group of Chinese and Turkish evangelical explorers said Monday they believe they may have found Noahs Ark -- four thousand metres up at Mount Ararat. (AFP/File/Hakob Berberyan)

Difficulties with a number of issues

Dr. Price, who is director of the Center for Judaic Studies at the conservative Liberty University in Lynchburg, Va., was the archaeologist on the Chinese-led team in 2008 when this alleged discovery was first made. He says he has difficulties with a number of issues related to the evidence at hand.

Price declined to elaborate. However, a leaked email from Price which he confirms that he wrote shows that he has reason to believe that a group of local Kurdish men trucked wood up to the mountain and staged an elaborate hoax for the Chinese team.

A group of Kurdish workers are said to have planted large wood beams taken from an old structure in the Black Sea area (where the photos were originally taken) at the Mt. Ararat site. During the summer of 2009 more wood was planted inside a cave at the site. The Chinese team went in the late summer of 2009 (I was there at the time and knew about the hoax) and was shown the cave with the wood and made their film, Price writes in the email.


This photo shows racks found on a wall inside a compartment of a structure that a group of Chinese and Turkish evangelical explorers claims might prove the existence of Noahs Ark, on Mount Ararat. Noahs Ark Ministries International/AFP/HO/Newscom

Price is a longtime searcher himself for the ark. As a member of Noahs Ark Search LLC, he had gone on a number of expeditions to Mount Ararat.

Price was not the only member to withdraw from the Chinese-led team over questions about their purported finding.



Video from: YouTube.com

Not good evidence

Dr. John D. Morris, who is president for Dallas Institute for Creation Research and has been a consultant to the team since 2005, says he declined an invitation to be a part of this weeks press conference in Hong Kong.

Im a scientist. I need to have good evidence, says Dr. Morris. As of right now, there is not.

Morris, who is also a fundamentalist Christian, led 13 expeditions to Mount Ararat between 1971 and 1990 as he searched for the ark. He has been in contact with the Chinese-led team for the past decade.

He says their finding is inconclusive and calls for more research. Video available on the teams web site shows the team exploring inside a wooden structure embedded in a sort of ice cave. The wooden walls of one compartment are smooth and curved. Morris says it is almost unfathomable that such heavy materials could be hauled up to 12,000 feet and lodged in the mountain ice without a major operation using heavy machinery.

I think it would be highly unlikely that anybody could carry wood up. I cant comprehend that. I dont think theres fraud involved. But that is a possibility. And only serious scientific work on-site can resolve that, Morris said in a telephone interview from Dallas.

The Noahs Ark Ministries International has no contact information on their web site, and the Monitor was unable to track down team members today for further comment. But in the press conference, they appeared to be aware that skeptics may question the findings.

"We are not saying that we are 100 percent certain that what we found is Noahs Ark. No one has ever seen the ark, no one knows what it looks like," said team member Yeung Wing-cheung. "We are only 99 percent certain that it is Noahs Ark based on historical accounts, including the Bible and local beliefs of the people in the area, as well as carbon dating."

Yeung would not reveal the location of the site because he says the team is waiting for the Turkish government to set up an official preservation area to continue their work.

Wood dated 4,800 years old

Morris, Price, and the Chinese-led team are a few of the many who have gone in search of the biblical boat. In the Book of Genesis, God commands Noah to built the massive vessel and bring every sort [of animal]...male and female ... everything on the dry land in whose nostrils was the breath of life. Then a 40-day flood hits.

A 2004 ABC News poll showed that 60 percent of Americans read the story of Noahs Ark as literally true.

Within that group of believers is a large subsection who believe not in a worldwide flood but rather a regional flood as is mentioned in alternative texts such as the Epic of Gilgamesh. However, a mere regional flood would not send Noahs ark up 12,000 feet on Mount Ararat.

Yeung told the South China Morning Post that a piece of wood obtained from the site was dated as 4,800 years old by a carbon-dating method in Iran. This matches with the range of years stated in the Bible, suggesting when the vessel was built.

Reinforcing a fundamentalist view

The discovery of Noahs ark would reinforce a literal interpretation of the Bible, says Claude Mariottini, an Old Testament professor at Northern Baptist Seminary outside Chicago.

People want to prove the Bible is true. If they can find the ark on Mount Ararat, it proves there was a Noah and a universal flood and its all true, he says.

If God is a God of truth then what the Bible says must be truth. If the story of Noah is not real, then for many people it puts their faith into question, says Dr. Mariottini, who believes the story is an allegory for how God is sovereign over creation and punishes sin.

The debate over evolution and creationism has increasingly called for hard evidence and empirical proof. And Christians have responded.

Modern science has challenged the Biblical narrative. For people who want to take the Bible literally, it drives them to look for this empirical evidence, says Carlos M. N. Eire, a professor of history and religious studies at Yale University, in New Haven, Conn.

Its not just about Christians, its about human nature, adds Dr. Eire. Its a very deep human instinct to search for truth in whatever you believe in and having physical contact with that.

Finding the ark would not prove anything

If this is Noahs ark, its not likely to drastically alter the perspectives of theists or atheists, says Eire. Fundamentalists would remain committed to a literal interpretation of the Bible while non-believers would continue to demand more evidence. Christians believe out of faith, not evidence, says Dr. Morris of the Institute for Creation Research.

It would not prove anything to me, says Morris. My faith is not in Noahs ark. But it would be an obvious physical confirmation based on what I believe.

The finding could divide Christians themselves, he adds, and provide fodder for evangelicals who believe that God flooded the entire world and, except Noahs family, killed off all humans because of their evilness. To recognize that God judges sin and that God will judge their sin is something [some Christians] would just as soon not believe in.

Previous expeditions have also come back from Mount Ararat with evidence of Noahs ark. French explorer Fernand Navarra found a five-foot section of the ark that was originally dated at 5,000 years old, though later shown to be only 500 to 750 years old.

This has happened before, says Eire. It will probably keep happening again.

Article from: CSMonitor.com



Related Articles
Noahs Ark Photo Gallery
Noahs Ark discovered. Again.
Natural history, Bible-style
Christian faith: Calvinism is back
Chinese explorers stand by claim of Noahs Ark find in Turkey
Noahs Ark Ministries International
Noahs Ark Search (Video)
Discovery of the real Noahs Ark Part 1: 2006 (Video)


Latest News from our Front Page

No Jab, No Pay reforms: Religious exemptions for vaccination dumped
2015-04-20 20:03
Religious exemptions for childhood vaccinations will be scrapped to toughen Australia’s new “no jab, no pay’’ laws stripping welfare from parents who refuse to vaccinate their children. Social Services Minister Scott Morrison revealed he is dumping the last remaining exemption on the books after holding talks with religious leaders. Just a week after The Sunday Telegraph revealed Mr Morrison was scrapping exemptions ...
Inside David Lynch: An Esoteric Guide to Twin Peaks
2015-04-20 18:24
‘I learned that just beneath the surface there’s another world, and still different worlds as you dig deeper.’ – David Lynch If you’ve ever sensed the flimsy, thin veneer of what parades itself as the good ole US of A, and felt a bit like you’ve been sold a fake, then David Lynch’s Twin Peaks is a series you must see. ...
Third-gender toilet sign – now a reality in Sweden
2015-04-20 18:29
If you don’t identify yourself as a man, a woman or are officially handicapped — where should you go to relieve yourself? In Sweden, the social justice warriors have solved the problem by inventing a third-gender toilet sign. A couple of years ago, the Swedish language was introduced to a new personal pronoun, “hen“, to replace gender specific hon (she) and ...
Feminist goes crazy when compared to Swedish nationalist
2015-04-20 4:56
A picture of a media acclaimed feminist next to a young nationalist girl got real big attention in Swedish media last week. It is “hate” and “mockery” to show the difference between the two, according to the collective Swedish press. When the young nationalist Hanna Lindholm (member of the Sweden Democratic Youth) published a picture on internet, where she compared ...
Massive pollution scandal in Norwegian fjord
2015-04-20 4:53
The Norwegian government today gave the green light to one of the biggest single instances of pollution in the country's history. A new mine will dump its toxic tailings directly into the Førde fjord in the west of Norway. "It is shocking that Norway is the only country in the world allow new projects of this kind", said Lars Haltbrekken of ...
More News »